Circus Animal Cookie Clone Failure


When I learned that Mother's Cookies was shutting down, I panicked.
I ran around my house, screaming, with my arms flailing in the air.
Then I mourned. I cried for days. Black circles formed around my eyes, and friends and family kept coming up to me, asking what was wrong.
"Are you okay?" They asked.
"No, no, I'm not. I feel like I've lost a dear friend."

I loved those pink-and-white frosted circus animal cookies, growing up. They were much tastier than regular animal crackers.

When I came to terms that Mother's Cookies were gone forever, I knew I had to clone them.



My first step was buying any remaining bags of cookies at the store, for experimental purposes, and by that, I mean... eating them. I found the bags and turned them around to examine the ingredients:

Sugar, Enriched Flour (Bleached Wheat Flour, Niacin, Reduced Iron, Thiamine Mononitrate, Riboflavin, Folic Acid), Vegetable Oil Shortening (Partially Hydrogenated Palm Kernel, Soybean, Cottonseed and/or Canola Oil), Skim Milk, Corn Starch, Contains 2% or Less of: High Fructose Corn Syrup, Corn Syrup, Salt, Leavening (Baking Soda, Ammonium Bicarbonate), Artificial Flavor, Eggs, Soybean Lecithin, Color (Containing Titanium Dioxide, FD&C Red No. 40 Lake, Red No. 3, Yellow No. 5 and No. 6, Blue No. 1 and No. 2, Red No. 40), Confectioner's Glaze, Carnauba Wax.

Oh.

Come to think of it, these cookies weren't that great after all. I mean, I haven't eaten them in years. I put the bags down, slowly backing away, and then took off sprinting out the door.

Yeah, I can definitely live without these cookies, and their waxy-hydrogenated oil coating. Hydrogenated oil and high fructose corn syrup scare me.

Anyway, I tried cloning them, using good ingredients, but I failed. I made shortbread teddy bears, drizzled them with glaze, and added some delightful sprinkles on top. But as you can see, they don't look the same. They don't taste the same, either. Not that they were bad... I thought they tasted pretty good.

I showed them to my dad.
Quote from Dad: "Those look disgusting."
Thanks, Dad.


But don't worry, Keebler produces frosted animal cookies too, in case you need a quick hydrogenated oil cookie fix.

SO, no recipe today. I leave you with my thoughts...

1. Never feel like you have to comment on here. Often I read blogs, but don't necessarily feel like commenting.

2. I watched Religulous. Has anyone else seen it? Thoughts?

3. Sometimes I drive to work and realize that I've paid absolutely no attention to how I got there.

4. I started reading Twilight, and it's sucked me in. Unfortunately. I wanted so much to hate these books.

Now if you'll excuse me, I have some reading to do.

49 comments:

  1. Hah, I am so glad you are reading Twilight, they are fascinating. I didn't appreciate the last one as much as the first three and Midnight Sun. I love them not just because she has the same religious background because Edward is just so darn yummy. I applaud the attempt of the cookie. The nasty ingredients that make them waxy are hard to purchase if you are not a major manufacturer!
    ReplyDelete
  2. I loved these as a kid but I had no idea how unhealthy they were. Oops! Glad you tried to make your own version! I will have to look for the other brands out there and read the labels:)
    ReplyDelete
  3. i can't believe you started reading Twilight!!!! my friend, Heather, has morphed all of her other friends into Twilight Nazis. she hasn't gotten me though... and she never will.
    ReplyDelete
  4. Oh good, I don't know why I couldn't get your comment thing to work before. Those cookies look so cute.

    I admit I didn't really care about Mother's. But then I just read that Mother's and Archway Cookies are owned by the same company (Archway's) and so now I feel for you about Mother's. They definitely should have consulted with you first, so you could have laid in a lifetime of supplies. And I guess those lovely Archway Dutch chocolate and oatmeal cookies (2 different varieties) may be gone forever. I liked the Dutch apple ones too.
    ReplyDelete
  5. I felt the exact same way about the Twilight books. My sister-in-law gave me the first one, and I was all like, "Haha, this is so stupid... Can I borrow the next one?"

    I vaguely remember the "icing" on those cookies being white-chocolate-esque... Maybe white confectioners coating (almond bark) would work? I dunno. I never really liked those cookies. I preferred the shortbread ones with the hard pink glaze and no sprinkles.
    ReplyDelete
  6. Hey - it looks like your comments are working now!! But mine still aren't... Hmmm....
    ReplyDelete
  7. Finally, I can comment! When I read the circus animals were going under, I e-mailed hubby with one word and the link: "horrific!" I swore I'd buy some at the grocery store that night. Then we got there, and it was $4.25 for a bag, and then i thought, Hmm, you know, they were kind of waxy and not so good, anyway.
    ReplyDelete
  8. I'm sorry to say that your teddy bears do look a little sad, but at least you know what went into them. :-)

    1. I often read blogs and don't comment.
    2. Haven't even heard of it.
    3. I only pay attention to where I'm going if it's somewhere I've never been before.
    4. Haven't read it, maybe I should.
    ReplyDelete
  9. I can't believe you said that about driving and not paying attention to how you got there...sometimes in the car I just get so engrossed in thinking (usually about nothing important) that I get to a place and am amazed I got there...I'm not sure but that might be dangerous. I just started reading Twilight too-not my usual kind of book, but I just had to see what all the fuss is about.
    ReplyDelete
  10. This is hilarious! I love your try at recreating the cookies. I still think they look cute! Weird about the comment issue. I haven't been able to comment on a number of blogs. Weird!
    ReplyDelete
  11. You are awesome! I'm so glad you made these. I was/am/will be devastated too :(. BTW, everywhere I go I hear about how awesome that series is...what makes it so addicting? :P am i really missing out?!
    ReplyDelete
  12. OH I loved these cookies too!! I'm not so turned off by some of the icky ingredients -- haven't you seen those new commercials for high fructose corn syrup?? :) ha!
    ReplyDelete
  13. I think the teddy bears look good. I love shortbread!

    Twilight is interesting. I don't like her writing, but she does suck you in!

    Bitter unpublished writer, party of one.
    ReplyDelete
  14. i hear you on the driving and ending up no where! i do that a lot, too. so sorry about your animal cracker loss! i experienced a similar situation when i moved away from baltimore and no longer lived near the berger cookie factory. sigh. i make my mom mail them to me all the time. so good.
    ReplyDelete
  15. I think Dad was being a little cruel. You did the best you could with what you had to work with.

    Hope you liked religulous. I want to put it in my Netflix Queue.

    I am always saying I want to read more blogs, but I sometimes feel so obligated to comment in them all. I guess I have to learn if I want to read more blogs, I have to go easy on myself about commenting. But I do appreciate the fact that you comment so much in my blog.
    ReplyDelete
  16. I think I would probably find religulous rather offensive, plus i have no time to watch movies.
    a lot of my friends are reading twilight and love the series. wish I had more time to read.
    Good luck with reincarnating you favorite cookies--I'd eat your version and so would my son.
    ReplyDelete
  17. See, this is why I don't read labels!

    Must nick Twilight from my friend's teenager. Heard so much about it - good and bad - I'm betting I'll like it though. I haven't grown up much since I was a teenager :)
    ReplyDelete
  18. Love the Maher, but will wait for the DVD release. I haven't got anyone to go see it with. The fact that you drive and don't remember how you got there shows a preoccupied mind, I've been known to do it myself.

    As far as the cookies go, hey, as long as they tasted good, it's a success.
    ReplyDelete
  19. Ok, so I love your little cookies! They look good to me!!

    I just finished Twilight, read it in 2 days which is very unlike me. Just picked up the second book!
    ReplyDelete
  20. Ha ha...Cute post,you're so funny! Good attempt at re-creating the circus animals.

    I'm so glad that you're reading Twilight! Way to jump on the bandwagon. :) That's what the books do...they hook you in and then you don't get your life back for weeks. Be prepared.
    ReplyDelete
  21. Ahh I used to LOVE those Mother's Cookies animal cookies - too bad they shut down :0( And hey, I do NOT think that your cookies are a failure - they look great to me!!
    ReplyDelete
  22. I've never heard of these cookies here in Chicago...those ingredients though - lol...far from organic.

    I love commenting here - I'll be back around!

    -DTW
    www.everydaycookin.blogspot.com
    ReplyDelete
  23. i get to my destinations and wonder how i got there all the time. it's really pretty frightening, isn't it? is my autopilot really that trustworthy?
    meanwhile, i've gotta say--your dad's right. :)
    ReplyDelete
  24. I've never had Mother's Cookies, but maybe you can keep trying to clone it for the rest of us (using good ingredients)!
    ReplyDelete
  25. I tried to leave you a comment yesterday but it didn't work, so I'll try again. I loved those little animal cookies and I mourn their loss. Keep on trying!
    ReplyDelete
  26. It's always great to visit you and to leave comments! I comment because I have things to tell you... hope I'm not too boring!!! ;D

    So bad this cloning bear thing... What about trying something with gelatin? (you know I'm not an expert at all)

    Thanks for the book tip, maybe it's already translated to Spanish... I love reading♥
    ReplyDelete
  27. Experimental purposes only to buy and eat (lol) you go girl I fully agree with you on this one ;)

    I still think your cookies look cute too!

    Rosie x
    ReplyDelete
  28. Ha. You're funny. I have similar driving experiences (OK, everyday experiences ... scary.)
    gotta love dads — they're always honest.
    ReplyDelete
  29. Hi - Just passed a little award on to you on my blog!
    ReplyDelete
  30. That's funny you should mention you don't want readers of your blog to feel obligated to comment. I always worry when I comment on someone's blog they will feel obligated to comment on mine.

    I had a good chuckle over the visual of your mourning of the loss of your beloved animal crackers. (did I say that right???) I personally never heard or tasted them.
    ~ingrid
    ReplyDelete
  31. OMG WHAT?! mother's is shutting down?!? noooooooooooooooo i love those frosted animal circus cookies! noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

    and i'm so glad you're reading twilight; its such a beautiful book! and sooooo addcitive!
    ReplyDelete
  32. OMG WHAT?! mother's is shutting down?!? noooooooooooooooo i love those frosted animal circus cookies! noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

    and i'm so glad you're reading twilight; its such a beautiful book! and sooooo addcitive!
    ReplyDelete
  33. I will so miss my Circus Cookies. They really do take me back to my childhood.

    I have Twilight but have yet to crack it open. I figure I'm going to need some uninterrupted time.
    ReplyDelete
  34. Emiline I think your cookies are sooo cute!! I always love to come here, you know! I enjoy and laugh a lot!!
    Your Dad is how you??? (humor sense)

    Have a lovely weekend!! (read! and cook) Gloria
    ReplyDelete
  35. oh just enjoy twilight - get caught up in it and don't listen to all the reviews. i think it's good to disappear into a book every now and then. it's not a great literary treasure but it was sure fun. i have missed reading your blog! i was in israel! now i'm going to have fun and catch up. ps your dad is hilarious.
    ReplyDelete
  36. I was feeling panicky too when I read about the Mother's Cookie closure. Your posting of ingredients does help to ease the pain, though. :-) Preservatives are hidden well in sugar, though...

    Enjoy the Twilight saga...it definitely has a tendency to draw you in deep.
    ReplyDelete
  37. I have a favorite cookie too, I've always wanted to see if I could make a homemade version...the cookie Pepperidge Farms Sugar Cookies. Someday I hope I can find a good homemade cookie recipe for it. I'm sorry yours didn't work out the way you wanted them too.
    ReplyDelete
  38. I don’t know on how I stumbled upon this cooking blog., All I know is that I’d better check out the archives for a good read. Ha-ha! Just droppin’ to say hi!
    Oh. You might want to check this out: http://www.technocooks.com for uhm...a different "menu."
    ReplyDelete
  39. I'm gonna miss those cookies. I havent had one since I was like 12..I'm going to pretend that they're still delicious, when I know that if I had one today, I'd probably spit it out.
    ReplyDelete
  40. Hi Em, Glad I can finally comment too! Crazy blogs!
    I hate when I try to duplicate something with nasty ingredients with healthier alternatives and it doesn't come out the same.(As if it would, haha!)
    Oh well at least they were still good!
    P.S. I finally made your Caramel Macchiato only I made it hot. YUM!
    ReplyDelete
  41. Finally I can comment! And no, I don't feel obligated!
    I've never even tried these mother cookies and now I keep seeing them everywhere. Last week Anita (dessert first) also did a clone. So funny that I'm interested in a cookie that I have never had.
    And I can't believe you started the Twilight! All that facebook talk for nothing!
    ReplyDelete
  42. There's a surprise for you on my blog!
    ReplyDelete
  43. I saw Relegilous!. I was cynical at first. I love Bill Maher but I dont like anyone mocking what I choose to believe in. I dont go to church every Sunday, but I believe. Anyway I liked how he put this film together. He has doubt like a lot of people and is lucky to question it in a film. Some of the characters were over the top of course, but thats reality. In the end he pointed out all things done in name of religon are questionable more so because the evilness of man and their motives.Everything he pointed out is why I dont neccesarily adhere to more organized religon but it doesnt diminish my belief.
    ReplyDelete
  44. Good. Those Mother's cookies are nasty! ;) I think yours are cute! It kind of looks like you just glazed and sprinkled Teddy Grahams, though.

    I totally want to see religulous, but, um, it's not playing in ANY of the theatres around here in the bible belt. Go figure, right? LAME.
    ReplyDelete
  45. LOL - I have never had these cookies, but now I think I am missing out!
    ReplyDelete
  46. Lisa, I love Edward!

    Jo, that's what I thought...

    Sue, I don't think I've had those before. I think my Mom used to buy the ginger ones.

    Pumpkin, Haha. I need the second one!

    Amy, I think ours were expensive, too. It seems like they'd be on sale if they were going out of busines. Hmph.

    Veronica, Uhh, I ran a red light the other day.

    Culinarywannabe, Yes!! I don't believe them!

    Blonde Duck, exactly.

    Rachel, I did like Religulous.

    CDM, Moxie is playing it.

    Sara, I know! All I wanna do is read.

    Dorothy, I know! Not fair!

    Marla, my Dad thanks you.

    Annie, it's that time of year! Have to switch the drinks over to hot. :)

    Rita, I know, I lied..

    Courtney, thank you! I appreciate the review. I was wondering what people thought.
    It's basically what I've been feeling the past year. I liked the movie, although it wasn't perfect. They didn't spend enough time on certain religions.
    ReplyDelete
  47. Oh, MY. I didn't know they got rid of my absolute favorite cookies. And I ALSO didn't know that they were so horrendous for me. Yeesh. Maybe it's a good thing they no longer make them.

    Can I sponsor your efforts to recreate these delicacies? :)
    ReplyDelete
  48. Wow this was a long time ago, but I just read this post, and couldn't believe Mother's went out of business... so i googled it, and they're back! Even though I never noticed that they were gone, I'm glad they're back! I love the Coconut cookies!
    ReplyDelete

Sup?