Comments on Sugar Plum: Deep-Dish Caramel Apple Pie

This was amazing! Made it for Thanksgiving & it w...

2009-11-28T22:43:01.773-06:00

This was amazing! Made it for Thanksgiving & it was a huge hit! Thanks so much. Love your blog!

OMG - just made this pie, it was sooooo delicious!...

2009-11-19T21:43:57.108-06:00

OMG - just made this pie, it was sooooo delicious!

Jayden looks adorable as Yoda - your mom is clever...

2009-11-09T18:12:43.241-06:00

Jayden looks adorable as Yoda - your mom is clever to be able to sew (I am hopeless). And as for that pie - YUM!!!

what a cute lil nephew!! I never understood the a...

2009-11-09T11:11:28.061-06:00

what a cute lil nephew!! I never understood the apple pie and cheese thing either...but I am planning on making an apple pie for thanksgiving....and what is better than apple and caramel together?! Yum!

I was seriously thinking about making a deep dish ...

2009-11-08T21:42:48.026-06:00

I was seriously thinking about making a deep dish pie and how great it would be with caramel. Thank you for posting this recipe...you took all the work out for me!

Now to the fun part, making it!

ok this looks perfect, I don't care what you say! ...

2009-11-06T22:36:19.545-06:00

ok this looks perfect, I don't care what you say! I seriously don't get the cheese with pie thing either...what? I love how your nephew always finds the cheez its when he visits, my daughter is the same way- the first thing she does when we visit my parents is make a bee-line for the granola bars! haha

Eric, cheese is a subject that draws much passion ...

2009-11-06T14:44:05.481-06:00

Eric, cheese is a subject that draws much passion from people. They simply cannot contain their feelings on their love for cheese.
Think of all the happiness that cheese brings us in our day-to-day lives. Cheese pizza. Macaroni and cheese. Cheese enchiladas.

We must appreciate it. We must honor thy cheese.

Thank you. I know you love my pie.

Nice pie. Also, you can "hate on" whatever the he...

2009-11-06T14:18:32.225-06:00

Nice pie.

Also, you can "hate on" whatever the hell you want. So what if you offend a random cheese enthusiast? That's life.

Beautiful pie!!! I do love cheese with my apple pi...

2009-11-06T13:20:04.969-06:00

Beautiful pie!!! I do love cheese with my apple pie (sometimes I make a pie crust with cheddar in it), but ice cream is also great, of course!!

Be still my heart. I love this. I think apple pi...

2009-11-06T12:52:04.592-06:00

Be still my heart. I love this.

I think apple pie and cheese is a Yankee thing.

MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM...

2009-11-06T11:05:26.486-06:00

MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM,...I so love caramel sauce!! That pie looks excellent, Emily!!!

Mmmm, what a pie!

2009-11-06T10:45:27.223-06:00

Mmmm, what a pie!

I love cheese, but I don't have to have it with ap...

2009-11-06T06:14:28.878-06:00

I love cheese, but I don't have to have it with apple every time (nor the other way around).

Your nephew is so cute! And this pie is divine.

I love the caramel all over your pie! I agree- muc...

2009-11-06T05:30:25.962-06:00

I love the caramel all over your pie! I agree- much prefer that to cheese. Yet half the people I know want cheese.

Thanks all! Anon, yeah, I don't really hate chees...

2009-11-06T02:42:37.652-06:00

Thanks all!

Anon, yeah, I don't really hate cheese with apple pie that much. I was just trying to find a way to connect apple pie with that picture of my nephew.

Jackie, good question. I kind of like Gala because they're reasonably priced. I'm a big fan of Macintosh and Jonagold, too. Heck, you may even want to try Honeycrisp if they're not too expensive.

I don't like fruit pies, but the pictures are beau...

2009-11-05T23:05:41.871-06:00

I don't like fruit pies, but the pictures are beautiful. Might have to make it as a dessert for work some night!

Hi What kind of mixture of apples do you suggest ...

2009-11-05T22:15:48.960-06:00

Hi

What kind of mixture of apples do you suggest in making this pie.

Oh my, sweet apple pie! That looks really really ...

2009-11-05T21:50:26.933-06:00

Oh my, sweet apple pie! That looks really really good. I like a good crust on my pie, and hello, caramel?! And the pictures of the cute nephew, well, that's just frosting on top. ;)

Cheese, really? I have never heard of that! Looks ...

2009-11-05T21:40:24.316-06:00

Cheese, really? I have never heard of that! Looks delicious and your little trick-or-treater is a cutie!

Your nephew is adorable! Love his costume, I do. ...

2009-11-05T21:01:16.244-06:00

Your nephew is adorable! Love his costume, I do. :) This pie sounds very tasty. I've never been one for cheese on my apple pie...that just sounds kinda gross to me.

Oh, apples and caramel!!!! Love the combo. It look...

2009-11-05T20:25:53.054-06:00

Oh, apples and caramel!!!! Love the combo. It looks so divine.

Don't hate! Try adding a little grated cheddar to...

2009-11-05T18:27:25.849-06:00

Don't hate!
Try adding a little grated cheddar to the crust of your next apple pie. It's not gross =(
Having cheddar cheese with your apple pie is an English thing, although Canadians do it too.
I don't understand why people hate on things that happen to be different. Try it before you knock it, guys!

So I think we are so on the same mental wave lengt...

2009-11-05T17:19:12.966-06:00

So I think we are so on the same mental wave length, I have some delicious apples that will waste away and need to do something with them! I have never made a pie from scratch! Embarrassing, yet true!My relatives (on the married side) eat Cheerios with milk and a slice of cheese in the morning! I am so not kidding, weird!

Oh Emily I never understood that cheese-apple pie ...

2009-11-05T16:02:40.229-06:00

Oh Emily I never understood that cheese-apple pie connection either! And I love raw apples with cheese, but in a pie it sounds too "cheesy"! Your pie looks delicious and so does your cute nephew!

This pie speaks to me. Yum!!

2009-11-05T14:57:12.647-06:00

This pie speaks to me. Yum!!